How to Choose the Right Rocks for Tumbling

Choosing the right rough rocks for tumbling is one of the biggest factors in whether your rock tumbling project turns out smooth and shiny—or chipped, scratched, and disappointing. Many beginners grab any stones they find and toss them into the barrel, only to discover that not all rocks tumble well.

This guide walks you through exactly what to look for so you can select the best materials for beautiful results.

What Makes a Rock Good for Tumbling?

A “tumble-worthy” rock has three main qualities:

1. It Has the Right Hardness

The Mohs hardness scale—from 1 (talc) to 10 (diamond)—measures how easily a mineral scratches. For tumbling, hardness matters because:

  • Rocks of similar hardness wear down at the same rate.

  • Mixing soft and hard stones leads to pits, scratches, and uneven shapes.

  • Very soft rocks may dissolve or turn to mud in the barrel.

The sweet spot: Mohs 6–7
This includes agate, jasper, chalcedony, quartz, and petrified wood—favourites among rock tumblers.

2. It Has a Solid, Non-Crumbly Structure

Avoid rocks that are:

  • Porous

  • Layered

  • Fractured

  • Crumbly

  • Heavily included with softer minerals

These break down or trap grit, ruining the final polish.

3. It Has Rounded Edges and Solid Shapes

While tumbling can smooth out most stones, extremely angular pieces take longer, wear more grit, and may chip.

Choosing rocks with smoother edges results in faster, more uniform shaping.

Understanding the Mohs Hardness Scale for Tumbling

Why Hardness Matters in Each Stage

Your coarse stage is where most shaping happens. If one stone is much softer than the rest, it will grind away quickly, leaving you with:

  • “Sand” in the slurry

  • Scratched harder stones

  • Flat spots or pits

  • Inconsistent polish in later stages

How to Do a Simple Hardness Test at Home

If you’re unsure of hardness:

  • A steel nail (5–5.5 Mohs) can scratch softer stones.

  • Quartz scratches stones below ~7.

  • Look for streak color, grain, and texture to help identify rock types.

These simple tests can prevent weeks of wasted tumbling time.

Best Rocks for Beginners to Tumble

If you’re just starting out, stick to reliable, hard silicates. Here are the most forgiving options:

Agate

  • Consistent hardness

  • Takes a brilliant polish

  • Great for all levels

Jasper

  • Dense and durable

  • Many colors

  • Very beginner-friendly

Quartz

  • Readily available

  • Polishes nicely

  • Affordable and easy to identify

Petrified Wood

  • Stable structure

  • Great hardness range

  • Very popular among hobbyists

These materials produce some of the most satisfying, high-gloss results with minimal frustration.

Rocks to Avoid (Especially When You're New)

Soft Stones (Mohs 1–4)

Examples: limestone, calcite, gypsum, soapstone
Soft rocks tend to:

  • Slurry into mush

  • Pit or dissolve

  • Fail to take a high polish

Layered or Metamorphic Rocks

Examples: shale, slate, schist
These split, chip, or shed layers inside the barrel.

Porous or Brittle Rocks

Examples: some sandstone, weathered granite, overly fractured pieces
These trap rock tumbling grit and rarely polish well.

How Rock Size Affects Tumbling Results

Why You Should Mix Sizes

A mix of large, medium, and small stones ensures:

  • Better tumbling action

  • Reduced voids in the barrel

  • More efficient grinding

A good mix often includes:

  • 25–40% small fillers (or ceramic media)

  • 60–75% medium to large stones

Ideal Size Range

For typical beginner barrels (1–3 lb), stones around ½" to 1½" work best.
Avoid pieces so large they can’t rotate freely—they’ll just thump around, wearing unevenly.

How to Know If Your Rock Selection Is Compatible

Rule #1: Match the Hardness

Keep the entire batch within this guideline:

All stones within 1 Mohs hardness of each other.

Example: Mix agate (7) with jasper (6.5–7), but not with calcite (3).

Rule #2: Keep Similar Material Types Together

Tumbling quartz-based rocks together produces more consistent results.

Rule #3: Avoid Mixing Glass With Rocks

Glass can be tumbled, but it requires:

  • Its own batch

  • Gentle cushioning

  • More careful monitoring

Glass and rocks generally don’t tumble well together because they grind at different rates.

Tips for Selecting the Perfect Tumbling Batch

Inspect Every Rock Before Tumbling

Look for:

  • Cracks

  • Pits

  • Grit-trapping cavities

  • Soft veins

  • Weathered surfaces

Start With Small Batches of Known Rock Types

This helps you:

  • Learn how different materials behave

  • Troubleshoot issues more easily

  • Avoid cross-contamination between soft and hard stones

Invest in a Rock ID Guide or App

Knowing what you’re tumbling saves weeks of trial and error.

Final Thoughts: The Right Rocks Make All the Difference

Rock tumbling is a long process—so the materials you start with matter. By choosing stones with the right hardness, structure, and size, you’ll drastically increase your chances of achieving smooth, mirror-polished results.

Back to blog